Table 26Studies excluded from the clinical review

StudyExclusion reason
Adamsson Eryd 20161Incorrect study design, Incorrect population
Akanabe 19852Before 2000; incorrect analysis
ALLHAT collaborate research group 20003Incorrect comparison
Ambrosius 20144Incorrect comparison
Anand 20076Incorrect population (heart failure)
Anand 20085Incorrect population (heart failure)
Anavekar 20047No relevant outcomes
Anderson 20118Incorrect study design
Anon 20149Abstract
Arima 200610Study took place prior to 2000 date cut off
Arima 200911Incorrect population (not treated)
Arnold 200312Incorrect analysis
Asayama 200917Incorrect population, study design and analysis
Asayama 201215No relevant outcomes
Asayama 201418Incorrect population, study design and analysis
Asayama 201419Incorrect population
Asayama 201614No relevant outcomes
Asayama 201713No relevant outcomes, Incorrect comparison, incorrect population
Asayama 201816Already treated at baseline
Assmann 200520No relevant outcomes, incorrect comparison
Aydogan 201522Already treated at baseline
Baker 200023No relevant outcomes
Banach 201424Incorrect study design
Barengo 200926Incorrect study design, incorrect population
Barengo 200925Incorrect comparison, incorrect analysis
Beckett 201427Included in systematic review
Benavente 201328Incorrect analysis (not adjusted)
Benetos 200329Incorrect comparison
Blacher 200030Incorrect population
Black 200331Incorrect comparison, no relevant outcomes
Blood Pressure Lowering Treatment Trialists 200832Incorrect comparison
Bohm 201633Incorrect population
Borghi 200335Incorrect study design, incorrect interventions
Borghi 200434No relevant outcomes, data set before 2000
Boutitie 200236No relevant outcomes
Brimble 201637Not article
Britton 200938Incorrect population
Brown 200039Incorrect population, Incorrect comparison
Bulpitt 200142Incorrect population
Bundy 201744Conference abstract
Bundy 201745Incorrect comparison
Butler 201146Incorrect population
Carlsson 201347Study took place prior to 2000 date cut off
Conen 200749Incorrect comparison
Czernichow 201150Incorrect population, incorrect comparison, incorrect study design
Deckers 200651Incorrect population
Derosa 201452Incorrect comparison
Derosa 201453Article retracted
Dregan 201654Incorrect analysis
Estacio 200656Incorrect comparison
Ettehad 201657Systematic review; references checked
Fagard 199959Study took place prior to 2000 date cut off
Fagard 200460Incorrect study design
Fagard 200761Incorrect comparison.
Fagard 200758Incorrect population
Fang 200662Incorrect comparison
Feldstein 201463Incorrect population
Ferrucci 200165Incorrect analysis
Filippi 201066No relevant outcomes
Freitag 200367Review, references checked
Frontoni 201468Commentary
Fuchs 201169Protocol
Fuchs 201670Included in systematic review
Garrison 201771Incorrect comparison
Geraci 200372Incorrect population
Grassi 201673Literature review
Gueyffier 199775No relevant outcomes
Gueyffier 199974Study took place prior to 2000 date cut off
Gustavsen 200376Incorrect population
Haider 200377Incorrect study design
Hansen 200778Study took place prior to 2000 date cut off
Hara 201479Incorrect population
Head 201080Incorrect comparison, incorrect study design
Ho 201881Incorrect comparison
Hong 201882Systematic review, references checked
Howard 200883Incorrect comparison
Huse 200084Incorrect study design
In der Schmitten 201385Incorrect study design
Inoue 200786Incorrect study design
Isezuo 200387Incorrect population
Ishikawa 200888Incorrect analysis
Izzo 201190Review; references checked
Jacobs 201791Incorrect comparison
JATOS study group 200893Incorrect interventions
Johnson 199394incorrect population
Julius 200695No useable outcomes
Kagiyama 200896Study took place prior to 2000 date cut off
Kalkman 201797Meta-analysis; references checked
Karmali 201798Incorrect comparison
Kengne 200999No useable outcomes
Kim 2013100No relevant outcomes
Kokubo 2008101Incorrect comparison
Kono 2005102Incorrect comparison
Kshirsagar 2006103Incorrect population
Ku 2018104Incorrect population
Lachouri 2009106No relevant outcomes
Le 2017108No relevant outcomes
Lee 2012109No relevant outcomes
Li 2005110Incorrect population
Li 2014112Abstract
Li 2016111Adjusted for treatment
Lithell 2003113Incorrect study design
Liu 2009115Included studies before cut off 2000
Liu 2015114Incorrect population
Lonn 2016117Incorrect population, no relevant outcomes, incorrect interventions
Lonn 2016116Incorrect population, no relevant outcomes, incorrect interventions
Lopez-Paz 2010118Abstract
Luders 1002119No relevant outcomes
Lund Haheim 1995120Study took place prior to 2000 date cut off
Ma 2012121Inappropriate washout period
MacMahon 2001122Incorrect population
Mancia 2016123Incorrect comparison
Margolis 2014124Incorrect population
Mariampillai 2016125Commentary
Mehlum 2018126No useable data
Meredith 2008128Incorrect population
Meredith 2016127Incorrect comparison
Moraes 2017129Systematic review, references checked
Muntner 2017130No relevant outcomes
Myers 2016131Incorrect comparison
Nakamura 2006132Study took place prior to 2000 date cut off
Nelson 2015135Incorrect analysis
Ninomiya 2008136Incorrect population
Nissen 2004137Incorrect comparison
Ntaios 2011138No useable data
Obara 2007139Incorrect comparison
Ogihara 2008140Incorrect comparison
Ogihara 2010141Incorrect population (already treated)
Ohkuma 2017142No relevant outcomes
Okayama 2006143Study took place prior to 2000 date cut off. Incorrect comparison
Papademetriou 2016144Incorrect comparison
Patel 2007145Incorrect comparison
Patel 2017146No relevant outcomes
Pocock 2001147Study took place prior to 2000 date cut off
Pringle 2003148Incorrect interventions
Redon 2012149Incorrect study design
Remme 2009150Incorrect analysis
Rouleau 2004151No relevant outcomes
Ruggenenti 2012152Incorrect study design
Sairenchi 2005153Incorrect study design
Shapiro 2018154Incorrect comparison
Shiraishi 2012157Incorrect population
Singh 2012158Conference abstract
Sipahi 2012159Systematic review, references checked
Sleight 2009160Order cancelled
Sundstrom 2013164Incorrect population
Sundstrom 2014163Incorrect study design
Takase 2017165Incorrect study design
The ADVANCE Collaborative Group 2001166Incorrect interventions; incorrect analysis
Thomopoulos 2014167Systematic review, references checked
Thomopoulos 2014169Systematic review, references checked
Thomopoulos 2016168Incorrect comparison
Thomopoulos 2017170Incorrect comparison
Thomopoulos 2018171Systematic review, references checked
Thompson 2011172Incorrect analysis
Tiessen 2013173Incorrect interventions
Tillin 2011174Incorrect population
Turnbull 2005175Systematic review, references checked
Ueshima 2003176Study took place prior to 2000 date cut off
Veloudi 2016177No relevant outcomes
Verdecchia 2009178Incorrect population (already treated)
Vishram 2015179No relevant outcomes
Wan 2017180incorrect study design, incorrect study population
Wan 2017181No relevant outcomes
Wang 2005182Incorrect comparison
Webb 2010183No relevant outcomes
Weber 2010185No relevant outcomes
Weber 2013184Incorrect comparison
Weitzman 2005186Incorrect comparison
Wing 2003187Before cut off of 2000; previously treated
Wong 2013188No relevant outcomes
Xie 2016189Incorrect population; incorrect analysis
Yui 2004190Incorrect comparison
Yusuf 2009192Incorrect comparison
Yusuf 2012193Less than minimum duration; Incorrect comparison
Yusuf 2016191Incorrect population, no relevant outcomes, incorrect interventions
Zamorano 2011194No relevant outcomes
Zanchetti 2003195Incorrect comparison
Zheng 2015196Incorrect comparison

From: Evidence review for initiating treatment

Cover of Evidence review for initiating treatment
Evidence review for initiating treatment: Hypertension in adults: diagnosis and management: Evidence review C.
NICE Guideline, No. 136.
National Guideline Centre (UK).
Copyright © NICE 2019.

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.